Rare Genetic Variation and Outcome of Surgery for Mesial Temporal Lobe Epilepsy
Perucca P., Stanley K., Harris N., McIntosh AM., Asadi-Pooya AA., Mikati MA., Andrade DM., Dugan P., Depondt C., Choi H., Heinzen EL., Cavalleri GL., Buono RJ., Devinsky O., Sperling MR., Berkovic SF., Delanty N., Goldstein DB., O'Brien TJ., Andrade D., Sen A., Bazil CW., Boland M., Cavalleri G., Choi H., Colombo S., Costello D., Delanty N., Depondt C., Devinsky O., Doherty CP., Dugan P., Frankel W., Goldstein D., Heinzen E., Johnson M., Kwan P., Marson T., McCormack M., Mikati M., O'Brien T., Ottman R., Pandolfo M., Perucca P., Petrovski S., Radtke R., Rees M., Sadoway T., Valley N., Walley N., Wood N., Zuberi S.
Objective: Genetic factors have long been debated as a cause of failure of surgery for mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE). We investigated whether rare genetic variation influences seizure outcomes of MTLE surgery. Methods: We performed an international, multicenter, whole exome sequencing study of patients who underwent surgery for drug-resistant, unilateral MTLE with normal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or MRI evidence of hippocampal sclerosis and ≥2-year postsurgical follow-up. Patients with either sustained seizure freedom (favorable outcome) or ongoing uncontrolled seizures since surgery (unfavorable outcome) were included. Exomes of controls without epilepsy were also included. Gene set burden analyses were carried out to identify genes with significant enrichment of rare deleterious variants in patients compared to controls. Results: Nine centers from 3 continents contributed 206 patients operated for drug-resistant unilateral MTLE, of whom 196 (149 with favorable outcome and 47 with unfavorable outcome) were included after stringent quality control. Compared to 8,718 controls, MTLE cases carried a higher burden of ultrarare missense variants in constrained genes that are intolerant to loss-of-function (LoF) variants (odds ratio [OR] = 2.6, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.9–3.5, p = 1.3E-09) and in genes encoding voltage-gated cation channels (OR = 2.4, 95% CI = 1.4–3.8, p = 2.7E-04). Proportions of subjects with such variants were comparable between patients with favorable outcome and those with unfavorable outcome, with no significant between-group differences. Interpretation: Rare variation contributes to the genetic architecture of MTLE, but does not appear to have a major role in failure of MTLE surgery. These findings can be incorporated into presurgical decision-making and counseling. ANN NEUROL 2023;93:752–761.